New Archaeological Find Under Western Wall: Secret Subterranean Hideaway

As for the builders, each had his sword girded at his side as he was building. The trumpeter stood beside me.” Nehemiah 4:12 (The Israel Bible™)

To honor Jerusalem Day, the Israel Antiquities Authority (IAA) and the Western Wall Heritage Foundation unveiled their most recent and most astounding discovery:  a unique subterranean

Tehila Sadiel (Photo by Shai Halevi-IAA)

system hewn in the bedrock underneath the Western Wall. Archaeologists working in the Western Wall Tunnels discovered 1,400-year-old remains of a subterranean public building. 

Excavation and Conservation by the IAA workes. (Photo by Shai Halevi-Israel Antiquities Authority)

According to the Archaeologists: “This is the first time such a system has been uncovered near the Western Wall.” 

The discovery raised at least as many questions as answers provided, the most compelling being, “Why did people invest such huge efforts and resources in hewing such an impressive subterranean system 2,000 years ago, while life was going on in the homes above-ground?”

The question is even more compelling when asked in the Second Temple context of the building.

This system, the first of its kind uncovered in the area of the Western Wall Plaza and Tunnels, was exposed in excavations conducted by the Israel Antiquities Authority in the “Beit Straus” complex, beneath the entrance lobby to the Western Wall Tunnels. The excavations at the site, renewed about a year ago, were being conducted as part of the work to prepare for a new and fascinating tour in addition to the classic Western Wall Tunnels tour run by the Western Wall Heritage Foundation.  Researchers believed that the complex was used by Jerusalem residents during the Early Roman period, prior to the destruction of Jerusalem and the Second Temple.  The subterranean system was sealed beneath the floor of a large above-ground structure from the Byzantine period.

The discovery was made by students in a pre-military preparatory program in Jerusalem.  The students were integrated into the archaeological digs as part of the IAA’s educational policy, which is

Excavation and Conservation by the IAA workes. (Photo Shai Halevi-Israel Antiquities Authority)

focused on connecting youth with their past. The system they discovered is composed of an open courtyard and two rooms arranged in three levels one above the other, connected by staircases hewn directly into the bedrock. 

Excavation and Conservation by the IAA workes. (Photo Shai Halevi-Israel Antiquities Authority)

Dr. Barak Monnickendam-Givon and Tehila Sadiel, directors of the excavation on behalf of the IAA, said about their discovery: “This is a unique finding.  This is the first time a subterranean system has been uncovered adjacent to the Western Wall.  You must understand that 2,000 years ago in Jerusalem, like today, it was customary to build out of stone.  The question is, why were such efforts and resources invested in hewing rooms underground in the hard bedrock?” According to Dr.  Monnickendam-Givon and Sadiel “The rich array of findings discovered in this excavation shed light on the daily life of the residents of the ancient city.  Among other things, we found clay cooking vessels, cores of oil lamps used for light, a stone mug unique to Second Temple Period Jewish sites, and a fragment of a qalal – a large stone basin used to hold water, thought to be linked to Jewish practices of ritual purity.”

Mordechai (Suli) Eliav, Director of the Western Wall Heritage Foundation said in response to the findings uncovered: “I am excited, on the eve of Jerusalem Day, to reveal to the Jewish nation a new treasure trove of

Photo by Shai Halevi-Israel Antiquities Authority

impressive and fascinating findings that shed light on life in Jerusalem throughout the generations in general, and on the eve of the destruction in particular.  This finding epitomizes the deep connection of Jews with Jerusalem, their capital.  Even when there were physical limitations, prayer at the foot of the remnant of our Temple never ceased, and this is tangible evidence of this.”

At the entrance to the rock-cut complex, depressions were found that were meant to firmly fix door hinges and bolts. Round and square niches were carved into the walls along with small triangular niches for oil-lamps, as well as elongated carving for shelves.  These findings hint at the rock-cut system being intended for daily use.  “Perhaps it served as a pantry for an overhead structure that didn’t survive, or as a hewn space that allowed for

(Photo by Yaniv Berman-IAA)

subterranean living”.

The rock-cut system was completely covered by a plain white mosaic floor of a monumental public structure built at the end of the Byzantine period about 1,400 years ago and renovated during the Abbasid period about 1,250 years ago.

Photo by Shai Haleiv-IAA

The frequent renovations of the structure and its destruction reminded one of the IAA team members, Michael Chernin, of a letter from the Cairo Geniza dated back to the 11th century CE regarding the renovation of a synagogue in Jerusalem after the earthquake of 1035 CE. The renovation was undertaken thanks to a donation from the Jewish community of Tyre, Lebanon to the Jewish community of Jerusalem.

Dr. Barak Monnickendam-Givon at the subterranean system. (Yaniv Berman-Israel Antiquities Authority)

Toward the Fatimid period (11th century CE), the structure was destroyed and the findings in it were covered by a huge collapse until being exposed by these archaeological excavations.

The Beit Straus complex is named for the philanthropist Nathan Straus who purchased the structure near the Western Wall at the beginning of the 20th century and turned it into a soup kitchen that fed the poor of the city.  As publicized earlier this year, the Israel Antiquities Authority conducted archaeological excavations at the site during 2013-2015, headed by Dr. Peter Gendelman and Ortal Chalaf, during which a beautiful column capital from the Second Temple period was found. The excavations at the site, which aimed at connecting Beit Straus with the excavations under the Western Wall Heritage Center, were renewed in 2019, led by Dr. Barak Monnickendam-Givon, Tehila Sadiel, Michael Chernin and Ortal Chalaf.  According to Dr. Monnickendam-Givon: “The excavations at Beit Straus, under the lobby of the entrance to the Western Wall Tunnels, reveal Jerusalem in its glory: Jerusalem of people, religions, and a variety of groups who lived, worked, built, and glorified Jerusalem throughout the generations.”